CEE 298 SEM Seminar Series: "Oregon Supreme Court Seismic Retrofit and Base Isolation", Geoff Bomba and Steve Earl, Forell/Elsesser
Event Details
Constructed in 1914, the Supreme Court Building of Oregon is one of the state’s oldest continuously operating government buildings. To preserve the historic structure and its unique features, the Oregon Judicial Department (OJD) embarked on a $55M retrofit project to protect the structure for the future. The retrofit design, which utilized seismic isolation instead of conventional fixed-base seismic strengthening, proved to be the most effective solution for simultaneously improving seismic resilience and minimizing the impact of the structural strengthening on the historic fabric of the building. Built using a combination of archaic brittle materials, including unreinforced masonry (URM) walls, interior hollow clay tile walls, and tile arch floors, the original, fragile structure needed a reliable lateral load path. Through nonlinear response history analysis and utilization of the existing URM walls for lateral resistance, ASCE41 performance-based design methodologies were used to minimize the intervention to the existing building’s historic materials and preserve the building’s architectural character and function. Strategic seismic diaphragm strengthening enhanced the tile floor connections to new concrete shear walls located discretely at the building perimeter. Seismic base isolation, which is rare in Oregon, is the most effective structural system for reducing superstructure seismic demands such as interstory drifts and accelerations. A seismic risk analysis, using FEMA P- 58 methodology, characterized the significant benefit of seismic isolation over a conventional retrofit for protecting existing historical elements and enabling functional recovery after a significant earthquake. The seismic retrofit and isolation system were creatively designed such that the existing building remained on its existing footings during construction, which was beneficial to both construction cost and schedule. Only with seismic isolation and this unique construction implementation strategy was this four-story structural restoration able to become a reality. The Supreme Court Building was successfully re-opened in 2022 and is now one of Oregon's most seismically resilient historic buildings.